In August 1939, tensions rise in the relationship between Japan and the United States which is accelerated when Japan allies itself with Germany and Italy. As the signs of war between the two countries advances, the Japanese plan an attack on the American fleet in Pearl Harbor, Hawaii. Based on the non fiction books THE BROKEN SEAL by Ladislas Farago and TORA! TORA! TORA! by Gordon Prange and directed by Richard Fleischer (the American portion), Toshio Masuda and Kinji Fukasaku (the Japanese portion). Critically panned on its initial release, the film holds up quite well. The film eliminates any personal stories, there's no romance in the film, no big stars. It's an ensemble film told in a semi documentary fashion and this all works to the movie's advantage. The first half of the film focuses on the Japanese planning the attack and the U.S. overlooking the warning signs. After the intermission, the film focuses on the attack on Pearl Harbor. Even though we know what happened, it plays like a tense "race against time" thriller. The screenplay is adequate, no more but this isn't the kind of film that depends on its dialogue. It's the three directors that form the film's structural skeleton and propel the narrative forward (Jerry Goldsmith's score helps). I did find the "humor" inserted in the Pearl Harbor attack not only lame but offensive. The massive cast includes Jason Robards, Joseph Cotten, Martin Balsam, James Whitmore, E.G. Marshall, Wesley Addy, Edward Andrews, Keith Andes, Richard Anderson, Leora Dana, Jeff Donnell, George Macready, Leon Ames, Neville Brand, June Dayton and on the Japanese side: So Yamamura, Tatsuya Mihashi, Eijiro Tono and Susumu Fujita.
As usual De Witt, you review the film in concise prose and with a vividness I envy. But I disagree on this one. The Japanese segment is well done. But the American segment, Good God. I mean, Martin Balsam as Admiral Kimmel! Good lord, I wouldn't hire Martin to run a popsicle stand - let alone the biggest, most important fleet in the US Navy. And that's just one of the cast. I think Tora, Tora, was going for a "Longest day" vibe, but they forgot the difference between the two events. Pearl Harbor was just the Japanese launching a sneak attack that killed 2,500 Americans. It wasn't D-Day, it was 9-11. Anyway, its good the movie was fair to the Japanese, too bad it wasn't fair to the Americans.
ReplyDelete